With only one episode left in Only Murders in the Building Season 4, Charles (Steve Martin), Oliver (Martin Short), and Mabel (Selena Gomez) are on the verge of solving Sazz’s (Jane Lynch) murder case. However, another character may not see the light of day after the finale.
Following the trend of this hit Hulu series, a new murder typically occurs at the end of each season finale, leading fans to speculate about who might not make it to Only Murders in the Building Season 5.
While these potential victims will still be part of the next season, they may only serve as cases for the podcast trio to investigate.
That said, here are five possible characters who could be the next victim in Only Murders in the Building Season 5.
5. Uma Heller
Like in Season 2, where Bunny (Jayne Houdyshell) died and became the focus of the investigation, another character who isn’t closely connected to the trio may meet a similar fate, and that character could be Uma (Jackie Hoffman).
As a close friend of Bunny, Uma's relationship with her adds emotional weight to her potential demise. If the investigation into Bunny’s murder continues, Uma’s death could deepen the mystery and further complicate the narrative for Charles, Oliver, and Mabel.
While Uma often provides comic relief, her character has layers that could reveal hidden motives.
The series tends to draw parallels between characters and victims, so her possible death might mirror Bunny’s. However, it remains to be seen if Only Murders in the Building will take that route again.
4. Jan Bellows
Fans also speculate that Jan may meet her demise in Only Murders in the Building.
Although she doesn’t live in Arconia, that doesn’t mean she is safe from becoming the next victim. After murdering Tim Kono in the first season and returning in the fourth following her escape from prison, there is likely a significant reason for her reappearance.
This leads to theories that Jan may be involved in solving another mystery. However, if she gets too close to the truth or uncovers a major secret, the mysterious killer may want to silence her.
It’s also important to note that Jan received a threatening note in Season 1 from an unknown person claiming to be watching her.
If this individual is indeed the killer with ties to the very beginning of the show, it’s possible that Jan could be their next target, making her a wildcard in the unfolding drama.
3. Detective Donna Williams
With her connection to past investigations, particularly the unresolved elements from Season 1, there is a significant possibility that Detective Donna Williams (Da’Vine Joy Randolph) could become the next target of a mysterious killer.
Williams has been involved in various plotlines that remain unresolved, such as the poisoned dog case and Jan’s (Amy Ryan) threatening note. If she uncovers inconsistencies or decides to dig deeper into these past cases, her life could be in serious danger.
While fans would hate to see Williams go, her potential death could provide an interesting twist in Only Murders in the Building Season 5, aligning with the show’s theme of intertwining past and present mysteries.
2. Howard Morris
Compared to the previous season, fans are seeing much more of Howard (Michael Cyril Creighton) in Season 4.
While this increased focus is welcomed, it should also raise some alarms. The series tends to elevate characters before putting them in peril, making Howard a prime candidate for a shocking twist.
Howard has been involved in the ongoing mysteries at the Arconia and is connected to past investigations, such as the murder of Ben Glenroy (Paul Rudd) and other unresolved incidents.
This makes him a possible target for the mysterious killer who wants to eliminate anyone with knowledge of their crimes. Additionally, Howard recently adopted a cadaver dog, which could lead someone to his lifeless body.
Could it be that the producers are endearing him to viewers only to kill him off in Only Murders in the Building Season 4 finale? What a heartbreak that would be!
1. Loretta Durkin
This could be the biggest heartbreak in the series if it happens, but Loretta’s (Meryl Streep) death in Only Murders in the Building is a real possibility.
Loretta’s relationship with Oliver has been a significant part of the plot, and any change in their dynamic may lead to heightened tension.
While the two have enjoyed a happy romance, this is television, and not everything ends happily.
If someone wants to hurt Oliver, Loretta could become the target. Additionally, her potential death might be the show's way of preventing their wedding, which could drastically alter the trio's narrative.
In a series where no one is truly safe, Oliver’s love interest may also become a victim, adding another layer of suspense to the unfolding mystery.
The mystery of the next death will soon be revealed, as Only Murders in the Building Season 4, Episode 10 is set to be released on Tuesday, October 29, on Hulu.